Mobile Signing Devices for Bitcoin Compared
Compare approaches to turning old phones into Bitcoin signing devices: SeedSigner, Krux, Jade Plus, AirGap Vault, MetroVault, and DIY air-gapped setups.
Using Old Phones and DIY Hardware as Bitcoin Signing Devices
Dedicated hardware wallets like Coldcard, Ledger, and Trezor are the standard for offline Bitcoin key management, but they cost $100 to $250+. A growing category of open-source projects lets you repurpose old phones, Raspberry Pi boards, and inexpensive microcontrollers as signing devices that communicate exclusively through QR codes or SD cards, never touching the internet.
These DIY and mobile signing approaches range from purpose-built firmware (SeedSigner, Krux) to phone apps designed for air-gapped signing (AirGap Vault, MetroVault). Each makes different tradeoffs on cost, security architecture, and usability. This guide compares them so you can decide whether a repurposed device fits your threat model or whether a dedicated hardware wallet is the better choice.
Comparison Overview
The following table compares the major options for turning commodity hardware into a Bitcoin signing device. All prices are approximate and based on publicly available parts lists or retail pricing.
| Device / App | Hardware | Approx. Cost | Air-Gap Method | Secure Element | Stateless | Open Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SeedSigner | Raspberry Pi Zero + camera + LCD | $50–$70 | QR codes | No | Yes | Firmware + hardware |
| Krux | Kendryte K210 boards (Maix Amigo, M5StickV, etc.) | $30–$85 | QR codes + SD card | No | Yes | Firmware + hardware |
| Blockstream Jade Plus | Dedicated device with camera | $149–$169 | QR codes (also USB, Bluetooth) | Virtual (blind oracle model) | No | Firmware only |
| AirGap Vault | Spare smartphone (iOS or Android) | Free app + old phone | QR codes | Uses device secure enclave | No | Yes |
| MetroVault | Android phone (8.0+) | Free app + old phone | QR codes | Uses Android Keystore | No | Yes |
| Coldcard Mk4 (reference) | Dedicated device | $130–$178 | SD card + NFC | Yes (ATECC608B) | No | Firmware only |
For a broader look at dedicated hardware wallets, see the Bitcoin hardware wallet comparison.
SeedSigner: Stateless Raspberry Pi Signer
SeedSigner is an open-source project that turns a Raspberry Pi Zero (ideally the v1.3 model, which lacks WiFi and Bluetooth) into a stateless Bitcoin signing device. The total parts cost is typically $50–$70: a Pi Zero, a Waveshare 1.3-inch 240x240 LCD, and a Pi-compatible camera module. Pre-assembled kits are available from community sellers for around €45–$70.
The defining feature is statelessness. SeedSigner holds no keys on the device itself. Each time you need to sign, you load your seed by scanning a SeedQR code or entering your BIP-39 mnemonic manually. Once the device loses power, the seed is gone from memory. The SD card can be removed after boot, so no secret data is ever written to persistent storage.
SeedSigner supports singlesig and multisig workflows via PSBTs, communicating entirely through QR codes. It can generate seeds from dice rolls or camera entropy, calculate the final word of a BIP-39 phrase, and verify change addresses. It pairs with coordinator wallets like Sparrow, Nunchuk, and BlueWallet. The project does not currently support Taproot spending.
Because there is no secure element, SeedSigner relies entirely on the air gap and stateless design for security. If someone physically accesses the device while it is powered on with a seed loaded, the keys are exposed. The Raspberry Pi also runs a full Linux kernel, which presents a larger attack surface than a bare-metal microcontroller.
Krux: K210 Microcontroller Firmware
Krux is open-source firmware that runs on inexpensive Kendryte K210 microcontroller boards. Unlike SeedSigner, Krux uses a bare-metal RISC-V chip rather than a Linux-based Raspberry Pi. Supported boards include the Maix Amigo (~$50–$85), M5StickV (~$50–$55), Maix Dock (~$27–$35), and Yahboom K210 module (~$45–$61). You flash the firmware yourself from the Krux GitHub repository.
Krux supports singlesig and multisig wallets, signs PSBTs via QR codes or SD card, and includes tools for message signing, encrypted backups, and offline wallet descriptor review. Like SeedSigner, it has no secure element and is designed to operate fully air-gapped. The K210 chip runs no operating system, which reduces the attack surface compared to Linux-based alternatives.
The Krux project has not undergone a formal independent security audit. It is funded through OpenSats grants. Recent releases (through v26.04.0) have added new supported devices, improved descriptor and QR handling, and added safety checks for PSBT parsing.
Blockstream Jade Plus: QR Air-Gap Mode
The Blockstream Jade Plus ($149 standard, $169 metal edition) is a dedicated hardware wallet with a built-in camera that enables fully air-gapped QR-based signing. While not a DIY device, its QR mode is relevant because it demonstrates the same signing workflow that phone apps and DIY signers use: the companion wallet displays a QR-encoded PSBT, Jade scans it, the user verifies transaction details on the Jade screen, and Jade displays the signed transaction as QR codes for the wallet to scan and broadcast.
Jade uses a "virtual secure element" design: the device itself has no dedicated secure chip. Instead, it splits the encryption key between the device and Blockstream's blind oracle server (or a self-hosted server). This model means that the device alone cannot decrypt the seed without the oracle, adding a layer of protection against physical extraction. In QR-only air-gapped mode, users can bypass the oracle by loading a SeedQR directly.
QR air-gap mode supports Bitcoin transactions. Jade pairs with Sparrow, Nunchuk, BlueWallet, and Blockstream Green. For a head-to-head with other dedicated devices, see the Jade vs Coldcard comparison.
AirGap Vault: Phone-Based Air-Gapped Signer
AirGap Vault is an open-source app available on both iOS and Android that turns a spare smartphone into an offline signing device. The app is designed to never connect to any network. It pairs with the AirGap Wallet companion app (installed on a separate, online phone), and all communication happens through QR codes.
Key generation uses entropy from the device's audio, video, touch sensors, and hardware random number generator. The secret is stored in the device's secure enclave (iOS) or Keystore (Android), requiring biometric authentication to access. AirGap Vault supports BIP-39 passphrases, Shamir secret sharing for social recovery, and BIP-85 child entropy derivation.
For Bitcoin specifically, AirGap Vault supports SegWit transactions and can be used in multisig setups through Nunchuk. The integration with Nunchuk uses the BIP-48 derivation path (m/48'/0'/0'/2') for multisig coordination. AirGap also supports several other cryptocurrencies beyond Bitcoin, which may be a consideration for multi-asset users.
MetroVault: Android-Only Offline Signer
MetroVault is a Bitcoin-focused open-source Android app (requires 8.0+) available on F-Droid. It is designed as a pure offline signer for watch-only wallets running on a separate device, supporting Sparrow, BlueWallet, and Electrum as coordinators. The app requests only camera and biometric permissions and has no internet permission in its manifest.
Keys are encrypted with AES-256-GCM and PBKDF2 (210,000 iterations), backed by the Android Keystore. MetroVault supports singlesig and multisig wallets across multiple address types. Version 4.0.0 added a duress unlock feature (opens a throwaway wallet and wipes real data), BIP-48 cosigner export, and transaction verification checks.
MetroVault has not undergone an independent security audit. Its security model depends heavily on the underlying Android device: a phone with an unpatched OS or a compromised bootloader undermines the app's protections regardless of its own code quality.
Transaction Type and Protocol Support
Not all signing devices support the same transaction types and protocols. The following table compares protocol support across each option.
| Feature | SeedSigner | Krux | Jade Plus | AirGap Vault | MetroVault |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Singlesig | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Multisig | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes (via Nunchuk) | Yes |
| PSBT (BIP-174) | Yes (QR) | Yes (QR + SD) | Yes (QR) | Yes (QR) | Yes (QR) |
| SegWit (P2WPKH) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Taproot (P2TR) | Not yet | Yes | Yes | Partial | Yes |
| Message signing | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Output descriptors | Yes | Yes | Yes | Partial | Yes |
| Dice/entropy seed gen | Yes | Yes | No | Yes (sensor entropy) | No |
| Coordinator wallets | Sparrow, Nunchuk, BlueWallet | Sparrow, Nunchuk, BlueWallet | Sparrow, Nunchuk, Green, BlueWallet | AirGap Wallet, Nunchuk | Sparrow, BlueWallet, Electrum |
Air-Gap Methods: QR Codes vs SD Cards vs NFC
The air-gap method determines how transaction data moves between the online coordinator wallet and the offline signer. Each method has different security properties.
QR codes are the most common method across all mobile and DIY signers. The signing device's camera reads an animated QR code containing the unsigned PSBT, and the signer displays the signed transaction as QR codes for the coordinator to scan. This approach is fully optical: no electrical or radio connection exists between the devices. SeedSigner, Krux, Jade Plus, AirGap Vault, and MetroVault all support QR-based signing.
SD cards offer an alternative channel used by Krux and Coldcard. The coordinator writes the unsigned PSBT to a microSD card, which is physically moved to the signer. The signed transaction is written back to the card. SD cards can hold larger transactions than QR codes, but they introduce a physical medium that could theoretically be used as an attack vector (a malicious SD card with crafted filesystem data).
NFC is used by some dedicated hardware wallets (Coldcard Q) but is generally avoided in DIY and mobile setups because it requires close proximity and is harder to audit visually. For a deeper comparison of air-gap approaches, see the Bitcoin air-gap signing comparison.
OS Hardening for Phone-Based Signers
If you use an old phone as a signing device, the security of the underlying operating system matters as much as the app itself. A phone with an outdated, unpatched Android version may have known kernel exploits that could compromise key material even if the signing app is well-designed.
Recommended hardening steps for phone-based signing devices:
- Remove the SIM card and disable cellular radios, not just WiFi and Bluetooth
- Factory-reset the phone before installing the signing app
- Install only the signing app: no other apps, no browser, no email
- Enable airplane mode permanently and disable WiFi and Bluetooth in settings
- Use a phone with a locked bootloader to prevent firmware tampering
- Consider flashing a privacy-focused ROM like GrapheneOS (Pixel phones only) or CalyxOS for a minimal, up-to-date Android base
- Store the phone powered off in a secure location when not signing
Google Pixel phones (Pixel 3a and later) are commonly recommended for air-gapped setups because they support GrapheneOS, have verified boot, and receive extended security updates. Older Samsung and Xiaomi devices work for MetroVault and AirGap Vault but cannot run GrapheneOS and may have unpatched vulnerabilities.
Cost vs Dedicated Hardware Wallets
The cost advantage of DIY and phone-based signers is significant, especially for multisig setups where you need multiple signing devices. A 2-of-3 multisig with three Coldcard Mk4 units costs $400–$530. The same setup with three SeedSigner kits costs $150–$210, and with three old phones running AirGap Vault, the marginal cost is $0 if you already have spare devices.
However, cost savings come with tradeoffs. Dedicated hardware wallets offer secure elements, tamper-evident packaging, purpose-built firmware, and vendor-backed supply chains. DIY devices require the user to verify their own supply chain (did the Raspberry Pi or K210 board come from a trusted source?), assemble hardware correctly, and flash firmware from verified sources. Phone-based signers inherit whatever vulnerabilities exist in the phone's OS and baseband processor.
For users managing significant Bitcoin holdings, a dedicated hardware wallet remains the recommended choice. DIY and phone-based signers are best suited as additional keys in a multisig quorum, as backup signers, or for users who prioritize verifiability and open-source hardware over secure element protection. For research on multisig architectures, see Bitcoin multisig wallets explained.
When a Mobile Signer Makes Sense
Phone and DIY signers fit specific use cases better than others:
- Multisig quorum diversity: using different signing device types (one Coldcard, one SeedSigner, one phone) reduces the risk of a single vendor vulnerability affecting all keys
- Geographic distribution: inexpensive signers make it practical to place keys in multiple physical locations for inheritance or disaster recovery
- Learning and experimentation: building a SeedSigner or flashing Krux teaches you how Bitcoin signing works at the protocol level
- Regions with limited hardware wallet availability: a spare phone with AirGap Vault provides basic air-gapped signing where shipping dedicated hardware is expensive or impractical
- Temporary or travel signing: a SeedSigner loaded with a SeedQR can sign a transaction and then be wiped simply by removing power
Bitcoin Layer 2 protocols like Spark are expanding how users interact with Bitcoin through faster settlement and stablecoin support. As these protocols mature, signing device compatibility with new transaction types (Taproot, PSBTv2) will become increasingly important when choosing a signer for long-term use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an old phone as secure as a Coldcard for Bitcoin signing?
Not in most cases. A Coldcard has a dedicated secure element that protects key material at the chip level, purpose-built firmware with a minimal attack surface, and tamper-evident packaging. An old phone running a signing app relies on Android's Keystore or the iOS secure enclave, which were not designed specifically for cryptocurrency key management. The phone's baseband processor, OS vulnerabilities, and larger codebase all expand the attack surface. A phone-based signer is better than a hot wallet but weaker than a purpose-built hardware wallet for single-key setups.
What phones work best for air-gapped Bitcoin signing?
Google Pixel phones (3a and later) are the most recommended because they support GrapheneOS, which provides a hardened, minimal Android base with verified boot and regular security patches. The Pixel 4a, 5a, and 6a are popular choices because they are inexpensive on the secondhand market and have cameras suitable for QR scanning. Any phone used for air-gapped signing should have its SIM removed, all radios disabled, and ideally run a fresh factory reset or privacy-focused ROM with only the signing app installed.
Can I use a mobile signing device for multisig?
Yes. SeedSigner, Krux, AirGap Vault, and MetroVault all support multisig workflows through PSBTs. The standard approach is to use a coordinator wallet (like Sparrow or Nunchuk) on an online device, which generates the multisig output descriptor and creates unsigned PSBTs. Each signer scans the PSBT via QR code, signs its portion, and returns the partially signed transaction to the coordinator. When the required number of signatures is collected, the coordinator finalizes and broadcasts the transaction.
What is the cheapest way to build a Bitcoin signing device?
The cheapest purpose-built option is a Krux signer using a Maix Dock board, which costs roughly $27–$35 for the parts. SeedSigner kits run $50–$70. If you already have an old Android phone, MetroVault or AirGap Vault can be installed for free, making the marginal cost zero. For multisig setups needing three or more signers, mixing inexpensive DIY devices with one dedicated hardware wallet provides strong security at a fraction of the cost of three dedicated units.
Do mobile signing devices support Taproot?
Support varies. Krux, Jade Plus, and MetroVault support Taproot (P2TR) transactions. SeedSigner does not yet support Taproot spending as of its current release. AirGap Vault has partial Taproot support. If Taproot compatibility is important for your workflow (for example, using MuSig2 key aggregation or Tapscript-based spending conditions), verify the current release notes for each project before committing.
How does SeedSigner differ from Krux?
Both are open-source, air-gapped, QR-based signing projects, but they target different hardware. SeedSigner runs on a Raspberry Pi Zero, which uses a Linux kernel: this makes development easier but introduces a larger attack surface. Krux runs on Kendryte K210 microcontrollers with no operating system layer, resulting in a smaller codebase and reduced attack surface. SeedSigner is strictly stateless (seeds are never stored on the device), while Krux can optionally store encrypted seeds. Both lack a hardware secure element.
Should I use a phone signer for my main Bitcoin holdings?
For significant holdings, a dedicated hardware wallet with a secure element (such as Coldcard, Foundation Passport, or Bitkey) is the safer choice for a single-key setup. Phone-based signers are best used as one key in a multisig quorum, as a backup signer, or for smaller amounts. The combination of a dedicated hardware wallet as the primary signer plus a DIY or phone-based device as a secondary signer provides both security depth and quorum diversity.
This comparison is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or security advice. Features, pricing, and security properties change with firmware updates. No DIY or phone-based signing device has undergone the same level of formal security auditing as established hardware wallets. Always verify current capabilities against each project's official documentation before securing real funds.
Build with Spark
Integrate bitcoin, Lightning, and stablecoins into your app with a few lines of code.
Read the docs →
